July 2, 2008
This should be a post about a new antibiotic, but it’s not. Do you know why?
Because my power has been off for the last three hours. That’s right; Pacific Gas and Electric either doesn’t know or doesn’t care that I lost all yesterday to some vicious food-borne pathogen and did not have three hours to sacrifice to their putrid mismanagement of the power needs of the people of (large parts of) California.
So you’ll have to wait until tomorrow for the antibiotic article, and instead be satisfied with this small rant, inspired by the Great Pet Connection Food Poisoning Incident of 2008.
For the last 22 and a half years, I have fed raw foods to my dogs and cats. During that time, I’ve been told by dozens of vets that my pets are therefore at risk of dying a horrible death due to malnutrition and the jellification of their skeletal structure. This has not happened, and in fact, most of my raw-fed dogs have outlived their kibble-fed parents and littermates, and I have never had a dog or cat become ill or suffer any kind of symptoms related to a food-borne illness or disease of nutritional deficiency or excess.
So I was somewhat amused when I went to the Western Veterinary Conference in February and heard one of the conference speakers, who worked for one of the big pet food companies, address her fellow veterinarians on the subject of raw diets.
She wasn’t really against them, she said. It’s just that it’s impossible to really prepare a nutritionally adequate dog diet in a home kitchen, because apparently dogs have such highly specialized digestive requirements that you need a degree in biology and a commercial laboratory to formulate their diets.
That’s why we never had any dogs prior to the invention of pet food a hundred or so years ago.
And she didn’t really have a problem with raw diets, either, except for the fact that they’re dangerous.
Now, my little weekend adventure has served to confirm for me that food safety in this country is a huge issue. I already knew that, of course, given the pet food recall and the stellar work being done by the FDA and USDA on the recent salmonella outbreak. But given my track record feeding dozens of dogs and cats of all ages and states of health (carefully chosen and handled) raw diets, I have to guess that the risks of doing so are grossly exaggerated.
If I’d been sitting in that audience — okay, I was, but if I were a veterinarian with no experience feeding raw diets and who knew only what the pet food companies had taught me in vet school — I’d have been quite horrified to learn that raw meat is so completely filthy and contaminated that it’s literally impossible to safely handle it in a home kitchen.
Even when you wash the dishes used to prepare your dog’s raw dinner in a dishwasher set on sanitize, even if you wash them in bleach and hot, soapy water, they still have measurable levels of bacterial contamination on them after washing. Even the glass or stainless steel dishes.
So I was listening to this, and watching the hundreds of vets in attendance nodding their heads and taking notes, and I wanted to stand up and say, “Does the dish somehow know that raw meat is destined for my dog’s stomach and not my oven? Because what about the bowl I used to mix my meatloaf? What about whipping up eggs in a bowl before I scramble them? What about marinating chicken breasts? How am I supposed to make my own dinner, if what you’re saying is true?”
And then I thought a little more, and wanted to additionally ask, “If this is true, then tell me, oh room full of veterinarians: Why aren’t you all getting up out of your folding chairs and marching down the hall to the large animal veterinary seminars and asking your colleagues in agriculture exactly why this nation’s meat supply is full of feces?”
I didn’t want to embarrass Pet Connection, so of course I didn’t ask. But it does make you wonder. Why is food safety always framed as a home kitchen problem, when most outbreaks of food-borne illness are institutional — restaurants, nursing homes, that kind of thing?
Why are we constantly being cautioned that our food supply is so contaminated with fecal bacteria that we don’t dare give our dogs a scrap of trim from the Sunday roast, and large veterinary conferences tell us we literally cannot safely sanitize dishes used to prepare meat, for us or our pets?
Why do we pass laws that meat has to be sold with lengthy “safe handling” labels, instead of laws that there shouldn’t be crap in my food in the first place?